Top-5 All-Time Club HR Leaders Breakdown

A Blog By Brett

Editor’s Note: All the graphics I use going forward will come directly from Stat Soldier. Go check it out by clicking here!

It seems almost daily that we hear about someone setting a record or moving up the all-time list in some statistical category. Since I love homeruns, this made me think about how many active players will finish in the Top-5 of their respective clubs’ All-Time HR lists.

Turns out there are several active players who will not only finish in the top-100 all-time home run list, but also a few will finish in the top-5 of their current organization’s list.

Take a look at the list below. This infographic shows the active MLB leaders in career home runs as of April 26, 2026.

Notes:

All stats were taken down on April 26th, 2026.

(*) Next to any player indicates that they are still active in Major League Baseball.

(HOF) - Next to any player indicates that they have been inducted into the Hall of Fame.

After some digging…here are some fun facts I discovered!

• The Marlins, Blue Jays, Rays, Angels, and the Diamondbacks are the only five teams without a Hall of Famer in their Top-5 HR Leaders.

  • The good news is Mike Trout (Angels), Giancarlo Stanton (Marlins), and Paul Goldschmidt (Diamondbacks) are all potential Hall of Famers. Mike Trout is obviously a lock.

• 59 of the 151 players in their organizations’ Top-5 HR list are in the Hall of Fame.

• Alex Rodriguez put up 189 home runs with Seattle, 156 with the Rangers, and 351 with the Yankees.

  • If you took his Rangers numbers away, he’d still have 540 career home runs and be #18 on the all-time list instead of #5 with 696.

• 14 active players are included across these Top-5 organizational lists. The Diamondbacks have the most active players in their Top-5 (3), where only one of them still plays for the team…Ketel Marte.

• The Yankees (4), Braves (4), Cubs (4), and Red Sox (4) are the closest teams to having all five players ranked in the organization’s Top-5 HR leaders all be in the Hall of Fame.

  • Yankees (Aaron Judge) → Auto Hall of Famer Once Eligible

  • Red Sox (Dwight Evans) → Considered One of Best Players not in HOF {Eligible 2028 for Ballot}

  • Cubs (Sammy Sosa) → Club HR Leader (PEDs)

  • Braves (Dale Murphy) → Another Player Being Considered for HOF

• The Giants have the most as an organization —> 2,459

• The Rays have the least as an organization —> 827

National League East

• Atlanta Braves - 2,433

  • Hank Aaron - 733 (HOF)

  • Eddie Matthews - 493 (HOF)

  • Chipper Jones - 468 (HOF)

  • Dale Murphy - 371

  • Andruw Jones - 368 (HOF)

• Miami Marlins - 850

  • Giancarlo Stanton - 267*

  • Dan Uggla - 154

  • Hanley Ramirez - 148

  • Mike Lowell - 143

  • Miguel Cabrera - 138

• New York Mets - 1,170

  • Pete Alonso - 264*

  • Darryl Strawberry - 252

  • David Wright - 242

  • Mike Piazza - 220 (HOF)

  • Howard Johnson - 192

• Philadelphia Phillies - 1,683

  • Mike Schmidt - 548 (HOF)

  • Ryan Howard - 382

  • Del Ennis - 259

  • Pat Burrell - 251

  • Chuck Klein - 243 (HOF)

• Washington Nationals - 1,176

  • Ryan Zimmerman - 284

  • Vladimir Guerrero - 243 (HOF)

  • Andre Dawson - 225 (HOF)

  • Gary Carter - 220 (HOF)

  • Tim Wallach - 204

National League Central

• Chicago Cubs - 2,068

  • Sammy Sosa - 545

  • Ernie Banks - 512 (HOF)

  • Billy Williams - 392 (HOF)

  • Ron Santo - 337 (HOF)

  • Ryne Sandberg - 282 (HOF)

• Cincinnati Reds - 1,626

  • Johnny Bench - 389 (HOF)

  • Joey Votto - 356

  • Frank Robinson - 324 (HOF)

  • Tony Perez - 287 (HOF)

  • Adam Dunn - 270

• Milwaukee Brewers - 1,253

  • Ryan Braun - 352

  • Robin Yount - 251 (HOF)

  • Prince Fielder - 230

  • Geoff Jenkins - 212

  • Gorman Thomas - 208

• Pittsburgh Pirates - 1,440

  • Willie Stargell - 475 (HOF)

  • Ralph Kiner - 301 (HOF)

  • Andrew McCutcheon - 248*

  • Roberto Clemente - 240 (HOF)

  • Barry Bonds - 176

• St. Louis Cardinals - 1,668

  • Stan Musial - 475 (HOF)

  • Albert Pujols - 469

  • Ken Boyer - 255

  • Jim Edmonds - 241

  • Ray Lankford - 228

National League West

• Arizona Diamondbacks - 904

  • Luis Gonzalez - 224

  • Paul Goldschmidt - 209*

  • Ketel Marte - 172*

  • Steve Finley - 153

  • Christian Walker - 146*

• Colorado Rockies - 1,328

  • Todd Helton - 369 (HOF)

  • Larry Walker - 258 (HOF)

  • Vinny Castilla - 239

  • Nolan Arenado - 235*

  • Carlos Gonzálezv - 227

• Los Angeles Dodgers - 1,490

  • Duke Snider - 389 (HOF)

  • Gil Hodges - 361 (HOF)

  • Eric Karros - 270

  • Roy Campanella - 242 (HOF)

  • Ron Cey - 228

• San Diego Padres - 832

  • Manny Machado - 198*

  • Nate Colbert - 163

  • Adrian Gonzalez - 161

  • Phil Nevin - 156

  • Dave Winfield - 154 (HOF)

• San Francisco Giants - 2,459

  • Willie Mays - 646 (HOF)

  • Barry Bonds - 586

  • Mel Ott - 511 (HOF)

  • Willie McCovey - 469 (HOF)

  • Matt Williams - 247

American League East

• Baltimore Orioles - 1,608

  • Cal Ripken - 431 (HOF)

  • Eddie Murray - 343 (HOF)

  • Boog Powell - 303

  • Brooks Robinson - 268 (HOF)

  • Adam Jones - 263

• Boston Red Sox - 2,217

  • Ted Williams - 521(HOF)

  • David Ortiz - 483 (HOF)

  • Carl Yastrzemski - 452 (HOF)

  • Jim Rice - 382 (HOF)

  • Dwight Evans - 379

• New York Yankees - 2,427

  • Babe Ruth - 659 (HOF)

  • Mickey Mantle - 536 (HOF)

  • Lou Gehrig - 493 (HOF)

  • Aaron Judge - 378*

  • Joe DiMaggio - 361 (HOF)

• Tampa Bay Rays - 827

  • Evan Longoria - 261

  • Carlos Pena - 163

  • Brandon Lowe - 157*

  • Aubrey Huff - 128

  • B.J. Upton - 118

• Toronto Blue Jays - 1,289

  • Carlos Delgado - 336

  • José Bautista - 288

  • Edwin Encarnación - 239

  • Vernon Wells - 223

  • Joe Carter - 203

American League Central

• Chicago White Sox - 1,558

  • Frank Thomas - 448 (HOF)

  • Paul Konerko - 432

  • Jose Abreu - 243

  • Harold Baines - 221 (HOF)

  • Carlton Fisk - 214 (HOF)

• Cleveland Guardians - 1,333

  • Jim Thome - 337 (HOF)

  • Jose Ramirez - 291*

  • Albert Belle - 242

  • Manny Ramirez - 236

  • Carlos Santana - 227

• Detroit Tigers - 1,713

  • Al Kaline - 399 (HOF)

  • Norm Cash - 373

  • Miguel Cabrera - 373

  • Hank Greenberg - 306 (HOF)

  • Willie Horton - 262

• Kansas City Royals - 1,204

  • George Brett - 317 (HOF)

  • Salvador Perez - 307*

  • Mike Sweeney - 197

  • Amos Otis - 193

  • Alex Gordon - 190

• Minnesota Twins - 1,549

  • Harmon Killebrew - 559 (HOF)

  • Kent Hrbek - 293

  • Bob Allison - 256

  • Justin Morneau - 221

  • Tony Oliva - 220 (HOF)

American League West

• Athletics - 1,440

  • Mark McGwire - 363

  • Jimmie Foxx - 302 (HOF)

  • Reggie Jackson - 269 (HOF)

  • Jose Canseco - 254

  • Bob Johnson - 252

• Houston Astros - 1,547

  • Jeff Bagwell - 449 (HOF)

  • Lance Berkman - 326

  • Craig Biggio - 291 (HOF)

  • José Altuve - 258*

  • Jimmy Wynn - 223

• Los Angeles Angels - 1,428 (not counting Glaus)*

  • Mike Trout - 413*

  • Tim Salmon - 299

  • Garrett Anderson - 272

  • Brian Downing - 222

  • Albert Pujols - 222

  • Troy Glaus - 182

• Seattle Mariners - 1,464

  • Ken Griffey Jr. - 417 (HOF)

  • Edgar Martinez - 309 (HOF)

  • Jay Buhner - 307

  • Kyle Seager - 242

  • Alex Rodriguez - 189

• Texas Rangers - 1,355

  • Juan González - 372

  • Rafael Palmeiro - 321

  • Frank Howard - 246

  • Ivan Rodriguez - 217 (HOF)

  • Adrian Beltre - 199 (HOF)