6 Comments
User's avatar
John Bicknell's avatar

Stan Musial? Know he played the most games at 1B but you don’t list him there either. He played more in left than in right or center; more games by far in the OF than at first. Assume you have him somewhere but it seems he should be here.

Dan Reynolds's avatar

Agree Musial has to be in one

of the top tens!

Tom C's avatar

One of the best ever. Had he been a Yankee, he'd be at the top of the list.

Will Manzi's avatar

i live for these sorts of reads

Dan Reynolds's avatar

What about Lou Brock how do his numbers compare?

Ben Johnson's avatar

Perfect list. I had no idea about Big Ed!! That’s crazy.

Curious, I get and love leaving out cheaters and Pete Rose. But where would Rose land? I think he was a desirable human outside of his playing career and should be banned and not in the HOf but as a player, he played the right away. Although he only broke the hit record because he could write his own name down. No way he gets there in today’s game.